The latest NY Rock banter:

Today's News:
Music
Movies
Entertainment

NY Rock
Confidential:
Cyndi Lauper,
  Joan Jett, Paybacks,
  Dollyrots,

Patti Smith,
  Johnette Napolitano
  (Concrete Blonde),
  Joey Ramone
  Birthday Bash
  with NY Dolls, etc.

Henry Rollins,
  Janeane Garofalo,
  Marc Maron, Gojira,
  Machine Head,
  Debbie Harry,
  Miss Guy, Pretty
  Boys, Theo and
  the Skyscrapers,
  Glass Hand

Didi's Back:
Miss Lez 2007
Zombies Attack

Dear Dr. Dot:
Sex advice

Jeanne's & Otto's
(Incredibly Awesome)
Blog

Soft Porn Central

TRUE! Cartoons


 
CD Reviews by Jean Hsu   Rancid • Spineshank • Soulfly
 
Rancid CD cover
 

Rancid, Rancid (Epitaph)
Rancid's new self-titled album speeds by in one godforsaken blur. In true punk fashion, the album contains 22 tracks and runs a mere 38 minutes. Jumping from references to Chaucer, Don Giovanni, Charles Van Doren, and international political commentary, the songs are lyrically ubiquitous, sometimes darkly witty, sometimes stark, occasionally unintelligible, though the music is pure punk. The beat never lets up, and 40 minutes later you're spinning confusedly in the aftershock.

Warning: if your listening interests are Weezer-esque geek punk or surf punk, and you're looking for something to add to your collection, this album is probably not for you. It's heavy; though it has its mean hooks. "Black Derby Jacket" is by far the pop-oriented song on the album, with its Beatles-like riff (and distinctly un-Beatle-ly vocals). "Rwanda," too (both the name and the republic), makes for an unexpected, yet catchy, refrain: "Rwanda/your moon shines bright/Rwanda/over planned genocide/Rwanda/won't you be strong like a lion." Not your ma's protest song, but it sinks in after awhile. "Antenna," if you manage to catch it as it whizzes by, will also find you trying to sing along.

Ultimately, if you want real hardcore punk, then Rancid's newest offering won't let you down. If you're not a regular listener, however, you might accidentally comment that the album sounds like every other punk album you've ever heard, in which case rabid punk fans will humiliate you and your musical tastes, and the encounter may end up with you being called a "Nancy boy."

 Spineshank

Spineshank, The Height of Callousness (Roadrunner Records)
As tends to be the case with many heavy bands, Spineshank's first album focused more on the "heavy" than the "band." Spineshank's second attempt, however, The Height of Callousness, mixes in melodic phrases without compromising its own metal foundation. "Asthmatic" contains haunting harmonic verse, while "Synthetic" and "New Disease" are both catchy (as catchy as metal can be) and hard hitting. But don't hold this against them if you want head-banging material; The Height of Callousness is even heavier than Strictly Diesel, the band's first outing.

While Spineshank's debut album earned them a few laurels around the college radio circuit, it didn't quite have the distinctive sound that The Height of Callousness now displays. The playing is sharper, the songs more musical, and the band has become more recognizable, due in large part to the album's producer. GGGarth Richardson (of Rage Against the Machine, Kittie, among others) has helped the band find an identity in the sometimes sludgy sea of metal thrash bands. New producer aside, the band has also honed its songwriting skills. "Realize that I'm nothing I wanted to be/I can never change anything I've done/Because it's all I have left/Blame myself again for what I didn't do" writes Tommy Decker in "New Disease," a song faintly reminiscent of Faith No More. Despite this pessimistic self-assessment, The Height of Callousness is indeed a step in the right direction for Spineshank.

Max Cavalera of Soulfly
 


Soulfly, Primitive (Roadrunner Records)
Max Cavalera, former head songwriter/lyricist of Sepultura, begins Soulfly's second album Primitive by declaring: "Back to the primitive/fuck all your politics." Accordingly, Soulfly have gone back to square one, and they're progressing somewhat slowly. Primitive features, though not as prominently as in previous work, the Brazilian rhythms synonymous with Cavalera from his infamous Sepultura days. But while Cavalera professes that his blend of metal and Brazilian rhythms are leading the way to a genre called "world metal," the new album displays some of the same old metal tricks.

Primitive contains a high-profile collaboration with the uber-recognizably monikered Sean Lennon on a track called "Son Song"... about growing up from a young age without a father (which was true for both Lennon and Cavalera). Lennonphiles might be a bit surprised by the track, which is one of the album's most interesting songs, a blend of metal and mellow. As on their self-titled debut album, Soulfly bring in other guest vocalists, such as Corey (#8) of Slipknot, Tom Araya of Slayer, and Chino Moreno of the Deftones. All temporarily wrestle for the spotlight with Cavalera.

Truthfully, Cavalera's in-your-face anger occasionally feels like in-your-intestine constipation when it comes to lyrics, but obviously Cavalera didn't ride the path to stardom on the back of his cracker-barrel rants. "Soulfly II" is a gorgeous example of what he can accomplish with his sense of melody and Brazilian rhythm, and "In Memory of..." blends hip hop into the musical melting pot. But a great deal of the album is merely a tease for what longtime listeners of Cavalera know he can accomplish. Fans and casual listeners will find Primitive a good metal album, but for those who have heard Sepultura's Roots, Soulfly remain a band still heading away from the primitive.

September 2000

Related Articles:
Rancid: Interview with Lars Frederiksen
Soulfly: Interview with Max Cavalera
Soulfly at Ozzfest 2000

Send this page to a friend • Join our mailing list • Current stories • Classifieds

NY Rock Home Page

 
 
  
Other features:

- Join our mailing list
- Send this page to a friend
- Classifieds
- Gallery
- Contact us
  

Indie Bible

NY Rock Advertising